Photos by Flora Charner

In November 2010, a wave of violence hit Rio de Janeiro. Two of the city’s most powerful drug gangs had joined forces to protest against the state’s recent crackdown on organized crime. The Comando Vermelho and Amigos dos Amigos cartels had been squeezed out of their strongholds in the city’s southern zone, where they catered to wealthy narcotics consumers in beachfront condominiums. The cleanup was part of the city’s plan to increase security ahead of the 2014 FIFA World Cup and the 2016 Summer Olympics. The gangs responded by torching cars and public buses for several consecutive days during rush-hour traffic, causing massive chaos. There were many violent shootouts between uniformed officers and dealers. In one week, more than thirty people were killed. It was one of the most terrifying periods of Rene Silva’s young life, and also when he became a star.

Rene Silva walks out of his apartment in Complexo do Alemão.
Rene Silva walks out of his apartment in Complexo do Alemão.

At the time, Silva was a lanky high school teenager who liked writing and hoped to become a journalist. When he was eleven, one of his teachers had helped him create a newspaper in which he and his classmates could share stories about life in Complexo do Alemão, the shantytown where they lived. The single-page bulletin was printed on a beat-up HP printer that had been donated to their municipal school. Silva wrote his articles from the dinner table that took up most of the living room in the modest home he shared with his grandparents, uncle and younger brother Renato. His mother lived on the same street in a tiny apartment with his sister. In Silva’s house, the television was always on. At 8:30 p.m. he would park himself in front of the small screen and tune in to Globo, his favorite network, to watch his idol William Bonner anchor the evening news.

By the time he was fourteen, his monthly publication had caught the attention of a local NGO that helps young entrepreneurs in impoverished neighborhoods. The Future Citizens Project donated a laptop, workspace and funds to publish the newspaper. Local businesses from Alemão also became interested in advertising in Voz da Comunidade (which translates to “Community Voice” in English) and began buying space at $0.25 a line. The junior reporters had managed to bring attention to the stories they cared about, like the lack of public services in the community and challenges with mobility, reaching an audience of roughly 5,000 people per issue.

“I felt like the major media outlets were missing some of our stories,” Silva says, speaking recently near his hillside home. “They would only show our community as somewhere violent and full of criminals.”

*   *   *

The Alemão, a conglomerate of shantytowns known as favelas, spreads over several mountains in northern Rio. It is home to nearly 200,000 people, most of whom live in impoverished conditions. Brick houses with zinc rooftops are crammed together and dot the mostly unpaved roads, while tangled power lines hang like vines. Its name, which translates to “German” in Portuguese, dates back to the 1920s, when a Polish man, Leonard Kaczmarkiewicz, purchased the then-rural land for farming purposes. Due to his fair features and untranslatable surname, the locals gave him the nickname “Alemão.” With the opening of a nearby factory in the 1950s, migrant workers from the northeast began to build their homes in the area. Kaczmarkiewicz left soon after and parceled off his land to the community, which named the neighborhood after him. However, the local government considered its residents to be squatters and staged aggressive police raids to destroy the emerging slums and evacuate the people. In 1983, the populist governor Leonel Brizola was elected in Rio de Janeiro and made it illegal for officers to enter the favelas, thereby halting the removals. Subsequent administrations criticized Brizola for incentivizing the expansion of the city’s shantytowns. By the time he left office in 1994, Alemão had grown into a small metropolis on the edge of central Rio, bereft of basic services and abandoned by the government.

A view of the cable car system and houses in Complexo do Alemão.
A view of the cable car system and houses in Complexo do Alemão.

At the same time, Colombian cocaine started traveling through Rio’s ports on its way to Europe. By the mid-’90s, the drug had become extremely popular in Brazil, and the local dealers turned immense profits. With money came power and the ability of gang leaders, known as donos, to keep corruptible politicians and police officers in their pockets. Drug traffickers of the Comando Vermelho gang soon found a home inside the hilly fortress of Alemão and established a parallel government within the community. Basic services that were once lacking, like running water and electricity, were now administered by the cartel. Instead of paying government taxes, residents were either charged fees by the drug lords or bartered with them to exchange goods.

“When the traffickers were in charge, we all knew we had to live by their rules,” Silva says. “As long as you kept your head down and didn’t cause trouble, you were safe in the community. We would end up with all kinds of things here, even free Coca-Cola.”

Silva explains that the gangsters would frequently set up roadblocks or booby traps that would cause delivery trucks to flip over, spilling all their merchandise onto the street. He remembers once seeing a red Coke truck on its side and running up to it. He and his friends got to taste the sweet beverage for the first time. When I ask him about the truck drivers and their fate, he stares blankly before answering.

“I don’t know, I’m assuming they ran away. At least I hope they did.”

As cocaine profits continued to soar, greed caused division and rivalries within the Comando Vermelho. New gangs like the Terceiro Comando and Amigos dos Amigos were formed and began staking out territory in other favelas throughout the city. Rivalries led to an arms race and the machetes and handguns used for protection were soon replaced by AK-47s smuggled across the Bolivian border.

In 2007, Rio de Janeiro hosted the Pan-American Games, a regional sporting event that is sort of a mini-Olympics. It was the first major tournament the city had organized in decades. In order to guarantee the safety of athletes and tourists, Rio’s elite military police squad, known as BOPE, was deployed to the place where security officials anticipated the biggest threat: the Complexo do Alemão. Criminals from the area had recently been accused of killing two police officers at a nearby police station. In late June, a few weeks before the Games were scheduled to begin, the officers carried out an aggressive raid. Nineteen people were killed in one day, eleven of them believed to be innocent bystanders caught in the crossfire. Witnesses and relatives of several of the victims claimed police dragged people from their homes and shot them point blank. Others were killed by stray bullets. The incident led to an investigation by the United Nations Human Rights Council, which criticized the police's approach to confronting criminal activity in the favela.

“It was awful,” Silva recalls. “Some of the kids that were killed were the same age as me.”

Following criticism from national and international human rights organizations, Rio’s state security officials began to work on a different approach. A year later, the Pacifying Police Units, or UPPs, were born. The UPPs are permanent community police posts that operate inside the favelas. Instead of surprising drug traffickers with raids, state officials announce their plans on television beforehand, allowing criminals to turn in their weapons anonymously or flee.

*   *   *

By late 2010, eleven favelas had been “pacified” in Rio de Janeiro. Silva, who was seventeen, was still writing and had developed an interest in computers and social media. His cousin bought him a laptop and his family purchased a basic and affordable Internet plan, which allowed him to surf the Web for news and ideas. He opened a Twitter account and began posting things under his personal username and his paper’s handle, @vozdacomunidade, covering mudslides in the community, the concerts of local artists, and always, the incessant battle between bandits and police.

Rene Silva updates his blog, Voz Da Comunidade, inside the small apartment he shares with his grandparents, uncle, and two brothers.
Rene Silva updates his blog, Voz Da Comunidade, inside the small apartment he shares with his grandparents, uncle, and two brothers.

On November 28, Silva was awakened by the loud swoosh of helicopters flying above his house. He turned on the television and saw live aerial images of his community broadcast on Globo. The camera zoomed in on large M113 camouflage tanks parked at the entrance of the favela and showed the area swarming with BOPE officers. A young woman appeared on camera wearing a bright blue flak jacket. As she spoke, her cameraman panned and showed dozens of other journalists on the scene. The newscast switched to an aerial to show the police line moving in on one of the neighborhood’s main access points. That’s when Silva heard a popping noise outside his window, which echoed through his monitor's speakers. He knew they were gunshots. The battle for Alemão had begun.

The young Globo reporter now appeared crouching on the ground in the same location. Her calm voice grew agitated and she was out of breath. She said the police incursion had begun and that the press corps were not allowed to join because it was too dangerous. As he watched the reports broadcast on several channels and read stories online, Silva began to come across inconsistencies and mistakes. Tweeting under the @vozdacomunidade handle, he corrected street names and other errors, and, through his fleet of journalists and contributors, kept track of how many people were injured.

"We were much more familiar with this area than the mainstream media," Silva says. "Plus, we were the only ones with access inside the favela."

He recruited two other Voz reporters and they began live tweeting every detail of the police operation from his dining room table. Tweets like “Intense shootout happening right now in Alemão people” were blasted out and reposted by others on their own Facebook and Twitter accounts. The local O Globo newspaper picked up one of his tweets and used it in a story, citing Voz da Comunidade as its source. The Globo anchor also read some of his tweets on the air and mentioned Silva by name. Within seventy-two hours, the police had chased some traffickers out of the favela and arrested others. At least four people were killed and several others injured. In the same time frame, Voz had gone from 180 Twitter followers to 29,000.

“We just kept tweeting what we were seeing because everyone wanted to know what was happening,” Silva says. “People from outside Brazil, famous people I had never met, began messaging me. I never thought it would get all this attention.”

*   *   *

Alemão currently has four UPPs operating within the favela complex. In at least some ways, things have started to turn around. According to officials, homicides have dropped by nearly eighty percent during the past three years. In 2011, the federal government installed a $131 million cable car system, connecting the sea of hills and providing mobility to roughly 12,000 people on a daily basis. The teleférico has also become popular with tourists, allowing visitors to float over the small brick houses aboard tear-shaped red gondolas. Some in the community still believe that the “pacification” is a maquiagem, an attempt to cover up the real problems that continue to exist in Alemão. Many people still complain about things like the lack of trash pickup and maintain that the money used to build the trolley should have gone toward education or healthcare.

The shantytown was even featured on a popular Globo telenovela earlier this year. Silva, now twenty, appeared on the television show, finally making it onto his favorite network not as an anchor, but as an actor playing a community blogger.

“Gloria Perez [the show’s creator and author] began following me on Twitter during the pacification in 2010. When she messaged me saying she wanted to film inside of Alemão, I could not believe it,” Silva says, trying to hide a grin. “When she said she wanted me to appear with all these famous actors, I was even more shocked.”

The Voz Da Comunidade staff meets inside Complexo do Alemão to participate in a leadership training workshop.
The Voz Da Comunidade staff meets inside Complexo do Alemão to participate in a leadership training workshop.

In 2012, he was one of four Brazilians selected to carry the Olympic torch in London, and was flown to the Games by Coca-Cola, one of its official sponsors. It was his first trip outside of Brazil. Since then, he has written an autobiography and traveled to New York on a U.S. Consulate scholarship. A local cell phone company gave him an iPhone 4, which has practically become an extension of his arm. As editor in chief of Voz da Comunidade, which abandoned its print format and has become a successful online blog, Silva now manages a staff of sixteen reporters. The project is funded by several local NGOs and organizations, which donate money for computers and cameras, but it is entirely administered by the young journalists. Silva has now expanded his social media footprint to Facebook and Instagram, where he has thousands of followers.

During recent rain storms, Silva posted pictures and messages alerting authorities that people were trapped in mudslides and that homes had been destroyed. The messages helped civil defense officials find the victims and take them to a local shelter.

His goal is to grow the project nationally. “I would love to see reporting in low-income communities throughout Brazil,” Silva says. “We currently have two correspondents [beyond Rio], one in São Paulo and one in Salvador.”

Voz da Comunidade now has more than 128,000 followers on Twitter and Silva has more than 10,000 Facebook friends. He recently posted about a thirteen-year-old boy, whom he referred to as a “child prodigy,” who created his own Facebook page to “show the reality of Alemão.”

“He reminds me of myself when I was that age,” Silva says. “I’m happy to see others taking an interest in showing the realities of our community. I may have to recruit him to report for us someday.”

*   *   *

Flora Charner is a multimedia journalist based in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, and New York. She covers a range of topics, including politics, social inclusion, and poverty. She is a contributor to Al Jazeera English, the Associated Press, and America’s Quarterly.

Other stories from Patchwork of Poverty

Waiting for de Blasio

New York’s incoming mayor has vowed to tackle the city’s record-high homelessness. But outside a crowded Brooklyn shelter, the guys on the corner aren’t holding their breath.

The Town of Trash

Meandering in muck, running through recyclables and wading through waste—for the Coptic Christians in one impoverished corner of Cairo, garbage is a way of life, and it is everywhere.

No Job Land

Five years ago, Spain was flush with cash and the sky was the limit. Today, millions of unemployed citizens are clinging to their homes, despairing for the future—and demanding that their government finally take a stand.

Growing Upside Down

In small-town Peru, Juan Huachaca rises before dawn and works until dusk, hauling mud and building bricks to support his family. He also occasionally attends third grade.
Published with Marquee